Skip to content

Should I Replace My Roof or Preserve It?

Knowing when it’s time to replace the roof versus when it’s time to preserve the roof is crucial, especially in a climate like Central New York.  Here’s a breakdown of when to replace and when to preserve your roof in this climate:

When to Replace the Roof:

  1. Excessive Shingle Wear: If your roof’s shingles are severely worn, with missing granules, curling or cupping edges, it’s a sign of advanced aging. In Central New York, where winters are demanding, this wear can be accelerated. Consider replacement if the shingles are nearing the end of their lifespan.

  2. Bald Spots: When your asphalt shingles have bald spots where granules have worn away, they’ve lost their protective layer. This exposes them to potential damage from the Central New York climate, making replacement a wise choice.

  3. Multiple Missing Shingles: Frequent severe weather, including heavy snow and ice, can lead to shingle damage. If you have several missing or damaged shingles scattered across your roof, especially in cities like Syracuse, it may be time for a replacement, especially if repairs become recurrent.


  4. Visible Cracks or Tears: The freezing and thawing cycles in Central New York can cause shingles to crack or tear. Shingles with visible cracks, tears, or large splits are compromised and need replacing to withstand the winter elements.


  5. Sagging Roof or Warped Roof: The weight of snow and ice in the Syracuse, Manlius, and other areas can strain roofs. A sagging roofline indicates structural issues, which can worsen during winter. It’s a strong indicator that the roof needs replacement.


  6. Frequent Leaks: The ample precipitation and snowfall in Central New York can lead to persistent roof leaks. Water stains on ceilings or walls, mold, or mildew growth inside your home suggest a compromised roof structure. Address these issues with a replacement to prevent further winter damage.

When to Preserve the Roof:

  1. Moss and Algae Growth: Organic growth can be cleaned off and prevented from returning. This will certainly extended the life and shingles and preserve the roof for years to come. 

  2. Minor Shingle Wear: If your shingles show minor signs of wear, such as mild color change or minimal granule loss, they may still have some years of life left. In such cases, you can consider roof preservation methods like clear coatings or sealants, which can provide added protection against the winter elements.

  3. Localized Damage: If the damage is limited to a small area or a few shingles, and the rest of your roof is in good condition, it may be more cost-effective to repair the affected section rather than replacing the entire roof. This is especially practical in Central New York.

  4. Regular Maintenance: Routine maintenance, such as cleaning gutters, replacing damaged shingles, and sealing minor cracks, can extend the life of your roof and delay the need for a replacement, which is valuable in a demanding climate like Central New York.

  5. Energy Efficiency Concerns: If your primary concern is energy efficiency to combat the cold winters, you can explore options like adding insulation or reflective roofing materials to improve your roof’s energy performance, which can be particularly beneficial in cities like Syracuse.


In summary, in a challenging climate like Central New York, including Syracuse, Manlius, Baldwinsville, Skaneateles, and Camillus, it’s essential to assess the severity of shingle wear and your roof’s overall condition to decide between replacement and preservation.

Roof replacement is often necessary if your shingles are significantly worn, damaged, or if structural issues are present.

Preservation methods can be effective when addressing less severe issues and maximizing your roof’s lifespan, taking into account the Central New York climate and its winter challenges. Consulting with a professional roofing contractor familiar with the local climate is essential to make an informed decision based on your specific situation.